Opinion & Analysis
New book suggests Hogan’s secret, how it can help you
Did you ever wonder exactly what the greatest ball striker of all-time was doing in the endless hours of practice he put in? One golf coach thinks he knows, and he’s laid out his findings in a new book: Hogan’s Ghost.
Further, golf coach Ed Myers thinks he’s unearthed the secret Hogan dug out of the dirt. More specifically, he thinks he’s uncovered the secret golfers can most benefit from.
The secret has less to do with pronation of the wrist or having “three right hands” and more to do with the concept of deliberate practice; it has more to do with a pencil and a notebook than any club in the bag, any strengthening or weakening of the grip.
Now before you write this off as another baseless suggestion as to what Mr. Hogan’s secret was. Do yourself the favor of reading on.
Myers is a golf performance coach who has taken a circuitous route to teaching the game at Memphis National Club. After years as a consultant and director of the Guaranteed Success Institute, Myers took up the game in middle age, determined to see how good he could get (and he got pretty good, routinely shooting under par).
Working with pro Rob Akins, Myers observed that most of the students he was seeing regularly weren’t getting any better. Ditto tour pros who were passing through working with Akins. He figured there had to be a better way to practice.
Thus, he turned the greatest practicer of them all: Ben Hogan. An investigation into Ben Hogan’s life, a close reading of Five Lessons, an understanding of Anders Ericsson’s concept of deliberate practice and Malcolm Gladwell’s “10,000 hour rule” led Myers to this conclusion: the passage below from Five Lessons contains Hogan’s secret.
“I found out that it helps me immensely to bring along a notebook and pencil to the practice tee and to write down after each session just what it was I had been working on, exactly how it was coming, and precisely where it was that I should resume my testing the next time I went out to practice”
What exactly was Hogan writing down in his notebook? Myers believes Hogan was essentially applying the concept of deliberate practice to golf.
And just so we’re all on the same page, this is how Myers defines deliberate practice:
[quote_box_center]“An activity that’s explicitly intended to improve performance by reaching for objectives just beyond your level of competence, while providing objective feedback on results involving high levels of repetition.”[/quote_box_center]
And how does one use the above to improve his/her golf game? Through a series of progressively more difficult drills meticulously documented in your workbook. And while there’s a more complex formula for determining acceptable error and this may not be Myers preferred standard, a progressive drill looks something like this.
Stock pitching wedge: 5 times cumulative miss not more than 50 feet (that is, the total distance of all the balls from the target is less than 50 feet). After this drill is mastered, a player moves on to a smaller target area and so on. Myers also advocates setting both “preferred” and “acceptable” standards.
Myers’ claim is a bold one. In Hogan’s Ghost, he firmly maintains that if you aren’t working with a practice book, you aren’t really practicing, and you aren’t practicing the way Ben Hogan advocated.
And while there is something self-serving in his claim (Myers has developed and sells his own practice workbook), there’s certainly a ring of truth in what he suggests.
The search for Ben Hogan’s secret is a wild, highly subjective fool’s errand, ultimately. The literal truth of Myers’ claim — that this is how Ben Hogan practiced — ultimately can’t be determined and can certainly be debated. What is not up for debate, however, is that with his workbooks and Hogan’s Ghost Myers has laid out an application of the concept of deliberate practice to the game of golf in a singular way.
If one truly wants to practice like Ben Hogan and ultimately improve, Myers’ thinking—and his texts—are more than worthy of consideration as points of departure.
As the editor-in-chief of this website and an observer of the GolfWRX forums and other online golf equipment discourse for over a decade, I’m pretty well attuned to the grunts and grumbles of a significant portion of the golf equipment purchasing spectrum. And before you accuse me of lording above all in some digital ivory tower, I’d like to offer that I worked at golf courses (public and private) for years prior to picking up my pen, so I’m well-versed in the non-degenerate golf equipment consumers out there. I touched (green)grass (retail)!
Complaints about the ills of and related to the OEMs usually follow some version of: Product cycles are too short for real innovation, tour equipment isn’t the same as retail (which is largely not true, by the way), too much is invested in marketing and not enough in R&D, top staffer X hasn’t even put the new driver in play, so it’s obviously not superior to the previous generation, prices are too high, and on and on.
Without digging into the merits of any of these claims, which I believe are mostly red herrings, I’d like to bring into view of our rangefinder what I believe to be the two primary difficulties golf equipment companies face.
One: As Terry Koehler, back when he was the CEO of Ben Hogan, told me at the time of the Ft Worth irons launch, if you can’t regularly hit the golf ball in a coin-sized area in the middle of the face, there’s not a ton that iron technology can do for you. Now, this is less true now with respect to irons than when he said it, and is less and less true by degrees as the clubs get larger (utilities, fairways, hybrids, drivers), but there remains a great deal of golf equipment truth in that statement. Think about it — which is to say, in TL;DR fashion, get lessons from a qualified instructor who will teach you about the fundamentals of repeatable impact and how the golf swing works, not just offer band-aid fixes. If you can’t repeatably deliver the golf club to the golf ball in something resembling the manner it was designed for, how can you expect to be getting the most out of the club — put another way, the maximum value from your investment?
Similarly, game improvement equipment can only improve your game if you game it. In other words, get fit for the clubs you ought to be playing rather than filling the bag with the ones you wish you could hit or used to be able to hit. Of course, don’t do this if you don’t care about performance and just want to hit a forged blade while playing off an 18 handicap. That’s absolutely fine. There were plenty of members in clubs back in the day playing Hogan Apex or Mizuno MP-32 irons who had no business doing so from a ballstriking standpoint, but they enjoyed their look, feel, and complementary qualities to their Gatsby hats and cashmere sweaters. Do what brings you a measure of joy in this maddening game.
Now, the second issue. This is not a plea for non-conforming equipment; rather, it is a statement of fact. USGA/R&A limits on every facet of golf equipment are detrimental to golf equipment manufacturers. Sure, you know this, but do you think about it as it applies to almost every element of equipment? A 500cc driver would be inherently more forgiving than a 460cc, as one with a COR measurement in excess of 0.83. 50-inch shafts. Box grooves. And on and on.
Would fewer regulations be objectively bad for the game? Would this erode its soul? Fortunately, that’s beside the point of this exercise, which is merely to point out the facts. The fact, in this case, is that equipment restrictions and regulations are the slaughterbench of an abundance of innovation in the golf equipment space. Is this for the best? Well, now I’ve asked the question twice and might as well give a partial response, I guess my answer to that would be, “It depends on what type of golf you’re playing and who you’re playing it with.”
For my part, I don’t mind embarrassing myself with vintage blades and persimmons chasing after the quasi-spiritual elevation of a well-struck shot, but that’s just me. Plenty of folks don’t give a damn if their grooves are conforming. Plenty of folks think the folks in Liberty Corner ought to add a prison to the museum for such offences. And those are just a few of the considerations for the amateur game — which doesn’t get inside the gallery ropes of the pro game…
Different strokes in the game of golf, in my humble opinion.
Anyway, I believe equipment company engineers are genuinely trying to build better equipment year over year. The marketing departments are trying to find ways to make this equipment appeal to the broadest segment of the golf market possible. All of this against (1) the backdrop of — at least for now — firm product cycles. And golfers who, with their ~15 average handicap (men), for the most part, are not striping the golf ball like Tiger in his prime and seem to have less and less time year over year to practice and improve. (2) Regulations that massively restrict what they’re able to do…
That’s the landscape as I see it and the real headwinds for golf equipment companies. No doubt, there’s more I haven’t considered, but I think the previous is a better — and better faith — point of departure when formulating any serious commentary on the golf equipment world than some of the more cynical and conspiratorial takes I hear.
Agree? Disagree? Think I’m worthy of an Adam Hadwin-esque security guard tackle? Let me know in the comments.
@golfoncbs The infamous Adam Hadwin tackle ? #golf #fyp #canada #pgatour #adamhadwin ? Ghibli-style nostalgic waltz – MaSssuguMusic
Episode #16 brings us Cliff McKinney. Cliff is the founder of Old Charlie Golf Club, a new club, and concept, to be built in the Florida panhandle. The model is quite interesting and aims to make great, private golf more affordable. We hope you enjoy the show!
Last week, I came across a reel from BBC Sport on Instagram featuring Scottie Scheffler speaking to the media ahead of The Open at Royal Portrush. In it, he shared that he often wonders what the point is of wanting to win tournaments so badly — especially when he knows, deep down, that it doesn’t lead to a truly fulfilling life.
View this post on Instagram
“Is it great to be able to win tournaments and to accomplish the things I have in the game of golf? Yeah, it brings tears to my eyes just to think about it because I’ve literally worked my entire life to be good at this sport,” Scheffler said. “To have that kind of sense of accomplishment, I think, is a pretty cool feeling. To get to live out your dreams is very special, but at the end of the day, I’m not out here to inspire the next generation of golfers. I’m not out here to inspire someone to be the best player in the world, because what’s the point?”
Ironically — or perhaps perfectly — he went on to win the claret jug.
That question — what’s the point of winning? — cuts straight to the heart of the human journey.
As someone who’s spent over two decades in the trenches of professional golf, and in deep study of the mental, emotional, and spiritual dimensions of the game, I see Scottie’s inner conflict as a sign of soul evolution in motion.
I came to golf late. I wasn’t a junior standout or college All-American. At 27, I left a steady corporate job to see if I could be on the PGA Tour starting as a 14-handicap, average-length hitter. Over the years, my journey has been defined less by trophies and more by the relentless effort to navigate the deeply inequitable and gated system of professional golf — an effort that ultimately turned inward and helped me evolve as both a golfer and a person.
One perspective that helped me make sense of this inner dissonance around competition and our culture’s tendency to overvalue winning is the idea of soul evolution.
The University of Virginia’s Division of Perceptual Studies has done extensive research on reincarnation, and Netflix’s Surviving Death (Episode 6) explores the topic, too. Whether you take it literally or metaphorically, the idea that we’re on a long arc of growth — from beginner to sage elder — offers a profound perspective.
If you accept the premise literally, then terms like “young soul” and “old soul” start to hold meaning. However, even if we set the word “soul” aside, it’s easy to see that different levels of life experience produce different worldviews.
Newer souls — or people in earlier stages of their development — may be curious and kind but still lack discernment or depth. There is a naivety, and they don’t yet question as deeply, tending to see things in black and white, partly because certainty feels safer than confronting the unknown.
As we gain more experience, we begin to experiment. We test limits. We chase extreme external goals — sometimes at the expense of health, relationships, or inner peace — still operating from hunger, ambition, and the fragility of the ego.
It’s a necessary stage, but often a turbulent and unfulfilling one.
David Duval fell off the map after reaching World No. 1. Bubba Watson had his own “Is this it?” moment with his caddie, Ted Scott, after winning the Masters.
In Aaron Rodgers: Enigma, reflecting on his 2011 Super Bowl win, Rodgers said:
“Now I’ve accomplished the only thing that I really, really wanted to do in my life. Now what? I was like, ‘Did I aim at the wrong thing? Did I spend too much time thinking about stuff that ultimately doesn’t give you true happiness?’”
Jim Carrey once said, “I think everybody should get rich and famous and do everything they ever dreamed of so they can see that it’s not the answer.”
Eventually, though, something shifts.
We begin to see in shades of gray. Winning, dominating, accumulating—these pursuits lose their shine. The rewards feel more fleeting. Living in a constant state of fight-or-flight makes us feel alive, yes, but not happy and joyful.
Compassion begins to replace ambition. Love, presence, and gratitude become more fulfilling than status, profits, or trophies. We crave balance over burnout. Collaboration over competition. Meaning over metrics.
Interestingly, if we zoom out, we can apply this same model to nations and cultures. Countries, like people, have a collective “soul stage” made up of the individuals within them.
Take the United States, for example. I’d place it as a mid-level soul: highly competitive and deeply driven, but still learning emotional maturity. Still uncomfortable with nuance. Still believing that more is always better. Despite its global wins, the U.S. currently ranks just 23rd in happiness (as of 2025). You might liken it to a gifted teenager—bold, eager, and ambitious, but angsty and still figuring out how to live well and in balance. As much as a parent wants to protect their child, sometimes the child has to make their own mistakes to truly grow.
So when Scottie Scheffler wonders what the point of winning is, I don’t see someone losing strength.
I see someone evolving.
He’s beginning to look beyond the leaderboard. Beyond metrics of success that carry a lower vibration. And yet, in a poetic twist, Scheffler did go on to win The Open. But that only reinforces the point: even at the pinnacle, the question remains. And if more of us in the golf and sports world — and in U.S. culture at large — started asking similar questions, we might discover that the more meaningful trophy isn’t about accumulating or beating others at all costs.
It’s about awakening and evolving to something more than winning could ever promise.
‘Why would anybody want to change that swing?’ – Brandel Chamblee says PGA Tour star was wrong to change his swing
‘The stupidest freaking thing I’ve ever heard’ – Billy Horschel slams Open idea suggested by Padraig Harrington
WITB Time Machine: Brandt Snedeker’s winning WITB, 2018 Wyndham Championship
Golfer proudly posts photo of ball mark on iron, receives immediate roasting
WITB Time Machine: Matthew Wolff’s winning WITB, 2019 3M Open
Oakmont Country Club bans Wyndham Clark over locker incident; Reveals specific conditions to earn reinstatement
Adam Scott puts Callaway blades in the bag at Wyndham Championship
Report: LIV star fires caddie and coach in shock shake up
Rickie Fowler makes equipment change to ‘something that’s a little easier on the body’
The championship formula: How 3 key stats separate winners from the field
Peter Malnati WITB 2025 (August)
Peter Malnati what’s in the bag accurate as of the Wyndham Championship. More photos from the event here. Driver: Titleist...
Cameron Young’s winning WITB: 2025 Wyndham Championship
Driver: Titleist GT2 (9 degrees, A1 SureFit setting) Buy here. Shaft: Mitsubishi Tensei 1K Pro Orange 70 TX 3-wood: Titleist...
Camilo Villegas WITB 2025 (July)
Camilo Villegas WITB accurate as of the Wyndham Championship. Villegas was undecided on a 3-wood when we shot his bag. ...
WITB Time Machine: Brandt Snedeker’s winning WITB, 2018 Wyndham Championship
Brandt Snedeker fired a final-round 65 at the 2018 Wyndham Championship to outlast Webb Simpson and C.T. Pan. His 5-under...
Ronald Ross
Aug 30, 2016 at 8:39 am
I am happy to say this is another baseless suggestion.
The answer has much to do with the hands (theory and practice), as revealed by golf instructor Sey,mour Dunn, on this site http://www.seymourdunn.com
cody
Feb 24, 2015 at 4:50 pm
when the legend becomes fact print the legend. Qoute the man who shoot Liberty Valance
Dlygrisse
Feb 20, 2015 at 5:49 pm
Just another guy trying to use some excerpt from one paragraph of 5 Lessons or some quick blurb in an interview with Hogan to write an entire book. The myth of Hogan is just too tempting for every wanna be teaching pro to resist. For goodness sakes when is it going to end? if you want to learn about Hogan he wrote 2 great books, read them. If you want to know what some guy that should be sued by the Hogan trust for using his name thinks then buy crap like this. Quite frankly I think books like this are disgusting at worst silly at best.
Gorden
Jan 25, 2015 at 1:16 am
Hogan was no different then Moe Norman, what they did in their golf swing and how they did it was a mystery to both of them……bottom line, hand eye skill just like every pro golfer out there.
Phil
Jan 20, 2015 at 4:40 pm
Guys, we covered this long ago. The secret’s in the Pantaloons.
h4ck
Jan 19, 2015 at 10:33 pm
I posted an excerpt of a Ben Hogan interview. I had to chime in…
Interviewer:Did you do any charting of the course — any note-taking? Or would you keep all of that in your head?
Ben Hogan: I tried to keep it in my head.
Interviewer: Didn’t you keep a notebook when you were practicing?
Ben Hogan: No. I get credit for all this stuff, but I didn’t do it.
Jim
Jan 19, 2015 at 12:14 pm
Bob – Thank you for the additional article, which I found most illuminating.
Gary McCormick
Jan 19, 2015 at 10:07 am
Deliberate, directed practice is a good idea, but not exactly a new idea – and the use of Mr Hogan’s name and the mention of his “secret” is just a cheap ploy to garner attention for Myer’s book amidst the teeming mass of golf’s game-improvement books.
MJ
Jan 18, 2015 at 5:23 pm
Hogan told his secret in Life Magazine If you would just read it and read it again about how it instantly changed his game overnight. If you say it didn’t then you didn’t read the article. Don’t say he lied in the article either
Bob
Jan 19, 2015 at 10:29 am
I read the Life article. I have a copy of it. I also read this post, A Very Revealing Hogan Letter, on Al Barkow’s web site: http://albarkow.com. You be the judge.
Golfraven
Jan 18, 2015 at 4:16 pm
Well, there is a true piece of advise and just for free – write everything in a notebook. Take pictures, make a journal, read it over and over again. Knowledge is king. See how your score will crumble – hopefully in the right direction.
No glove much love to the ball
Jan 18, 2015 at 2:17 pm
No glove, and an extra long, leather grip on the shaft, and not having to have to change his swing from the irons to the driver because the heads were so small on the old drivers that he could swing the same way and smash it off the low tee off the turf. Plus his lack of lower body movement but instead using a hip-bump to time his elbow tucking in on the right side and hinging that move into the ball as he hit it as hard as he could with the tightest grip imaginable.
patrick
Jan 18, 2015 at 1:20 pm
I played professional squash for almost 20 years and played internationally for about 7 years in the 80’s. I always kept a journal of all my matches and training. To participate on the national team we had to surrender our journals for inspection to prove we had been trainng and playing all the relevant matches.
What Hogan did was smart in that his career was a culmination of specific practice and then playing tournaments to see if he was practicing effectively. Today this is common amongst most pro sports. Somebody is always accumulating information to help improve their performance. Apparently Hogan was ahead of his time and realized his practice sessions were critical. If I were a pro golfer I’d do the same thing.
Jeffcb
Jan 18, 2015 at 9:13 am
Wow that’s really bad.
As far as I’ve read there’s only one teacher who figured it out and he explains it perfectly in one of his books. The “secret” won’t apply to every golfer but if you have a similar swing to Hogan, one plane, then it can be of benefit. Of course that’s if you were suffering from the same problem as Hogan, timing you’re release and fighting hooks.
Steve
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:46 am
What helps one golfer, doesn’t help all golfers. There can be one thing said or shown to you that turns on a lightbulb. That same thing means nothing to the next golfer. Everyone pro or amateur has their own golf demons.
RetiredCartBoy
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:20 am
Who knows – maybe the book is fantastic. It makes perfect sense to keep note about practice sessions as described. However, what would really make this work significant would be if he had access to the actual Hogan notebooks to learn the details of just HOW Hogan documented his practice sessions. For example, what sort of language did he use to describe how things felt. Otherwise, as others have said, this is just using Hogan’s name to sell a book.
I used to keep a notebook where I would jot down notes about some of my practice sessions and rounds. It was amazing to look back through and see just how many times I FINALLY figured out my golf swing. A pattern wasn’t too hard to spot. I’d make some sort of change, and would start hitting it really well. After a short time I would end up overdoing that move, play bad, then discover a new move to fix the previous one, and would play well for a while. Repeat, repeat, repeat. Though I was improving during this period, after a few years I really plateaued, largely because I never zeroed in on just one swing.
Larry
Jan 18, 2015 at 4:03 am
Hogan, Moe Norman, Tiger Woods (all Pros) have the same SECRET it is called hand/eye coordination linked with the ability to remember what you just did…How many of us hole out a sand shoot for a birdie on number 3 on Monday and on Friday have the same sand shoot and cannot remember how the heck we hit that same shot on Monday??? The Real SECRET to golf is frist be able to do it (275 yd drive) and second be able to do it over and over which is almost impossible for unskilled amatures…..how fast do we armatures forget how we swing??? How long does it take from the pratice tee to the first tee…..
snowman
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:01 pm
I totally agree that is good to practice/document status/repeat, but agree with others — this is just another guy trying to grab attention/book buyers by using Hogans name.
slimeone
Jan 17, 2015 at 6:15 pm
Interesting read, but it can’t be Hogan’s secret because he suggests doing this in 5 Lessons. His secret is supposed to be something that he omitted from his book deliberately. However having read his book many times, I have never actually taken a notebook during practice and often I think I probably should. The thing about Hogan’s instruction is that he expects the reader to follow it to the letter because that was how he played.
Todd H
Jan 17, 2015 at 6:13 pm
Great article, this will be a great help, I personally need more specific practice, and less mindless hitting shots
William Gilbert
Jan 17, 2015 at 4:17 pm
If you don’t believe that the identification of specific goals during your practice time is not beneficial, then I would be interested in joining you for a round or two.
Jon
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:22 pm
There is only one authentic Hogan swing, the rest are mere imitations.
Can't you see I'm eating my lunch?
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:48 pm
Ben Hogan’s REAL secret wouldn’t help anybody but him. It was probably just a random thing he “felt” in his swing that helped him repeat and to get in to a good rhythm. Trying to be Ben Hogan will only hurt you.
Furthermore, you can’t say Hogan practiced more than Lee Trevino, Moe Norman, Gary Player or Tiger Woods.
Moe didn’t have a wife or a life outside of golf. Didn’t smoke. Didn’t drink. Didn’t date. For years he would get up, hit balls for hours upon hours, and then play 36 or more.
The “10,000” rule does NOT mean that if you practice something for 10,000 hours you will be an expert, it is a guess as to what the average is. For some people it could be 3,000 hours, and some people could put 25,000 hours and not see any real gains.
Will practicing better make you a better golfer? Probably. But at the end of the day, this is a man trying to sell a book. If Ben Hogan was alive, would he authorize this man to use his name? People who knew Mr. Hogan know the answer to that question. Haha
Darryl
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:15 pm
Well said!
Can't you see I'm eating my lunch?
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:37 pm
Thanks